E-Collar vs. Shock Collar | What’s the Difference

You might be wondering about the controversy About e-collar vs shock collar. However, some do not understand what these collars are. Because the word shock is enough to give a powerful emotion to someone with a dog. You must not want to hurt your dog. But these collars are not harmful or provide a shock to your dog.

   Sadly, it is a misnamed that has filled negativity in others toward these collars. These collars are excellent for dog training and keep your pooch from getting lost or harmed. Basically, e-collar is comparable to a shock collar, and the name is used conversely, which is confusing.

   So in this blog, we try to eliminate the mythology about using e-collars and shock collars. Also, the difference between these two collars is that they are safe for your dog, their pros and cons, and their proper use. Thus, keep reading to learn more.

History of E-collar vs. Shock collar

   E-collars are known as electronic collars that were made in 1970. The purpose of these collars is to soften the behavior of dogs. Electronic collars use electric provoke that alert your dog to behave well by vibrating, not electric shock. Today e-collars and shock collars are available in the market.

   Both collar functioning is similar. The vibration brace the sense organs and nerves that divert the dog from the recent behavior. These collars help you to make the training beneficial and safe. Thus, your dog does not feel any pain or shock. However, they might feel friendly irritation and displeasure. Checkout the Best collar for your Dog.

What is an E-collar?

What is an E-collar

   E-collar or electronic collars use vibration to control the behavior of dogs. Modern e-collars utilize electric provoke that stimulates your pooch’s nerve by vibration, and also, your dog does not feel any pain. While there is no ache, your dog still feels displeasure. Hopefully, these collars will desist your dog’s aggressive behavior.

How Do they Work?

   Typically, e-collars have a cellular remote, and a receiver is linked to the collar. The dog wears the collar around his neck, and you can control it remotely. E-collars use electric provoke rather than a shock that you activate with the remote. This method is called negative evolution. It stops the dog’s behavior and sense of discomfort.

   Some e-collars are flexible, and you can change the potency of vibration according to the situation and your pooch. Some collars have just vibration mode that you can utilize as a reminder if your dog is calm. Some e-collars also have GPS trackers, so you can easily track your dog’s location.

Are E-collars Secure for your Dogs?

   Yes, these collars are perfectly secure for your dogs if you use them properly. The slight electronic stimulation will produce a vibration that your dog feels like a light flea bite, and he might feel discomfort. An e-collar does not hurt the dog even at a high level. But still, they will feel discomfort with the sensation.

   We advise you to use a lower setting at the beginning and see your dog’s reaction. You might need to maximize it, or your dog may change the behavior in a lower setting. Well, do not use these collars permanently; just use them while training.  

Using E-collar to Train your Dog

   You must start training your dog by using verbal commands and giving him a treat for good behavior. Although some dogs are stubborn and challenging while training, an e-collar is essential. Usually, e-collars are used to stop behavior such as excessive barking, growling, jumping on humans, nipping, and chewing items.

   Some dogs also show combative behavior by plunging over other animals and humans. So, here are the techniques to correct their bad behavior while training by using e-collars:

Train the Dog to Obey your Commands

   Follow these tips to train your dog by using an e-collar:

  • Let your dog be comfortable: Even though these collars are for temporary use, still let your dog be comfortable wearing this collar. Put this collar on your dog for a few days before training so that he does not feel uncomfortable.
  • Use lower setting: Always start training by using a lower collar setting and maximize the set slowly if it is necessary; otherwise no need for a high setting. Usually, the lowest setting is effective and cheerful for many dogs. Do not use a high setting; if you feel that you have to maximize the setting due to the dog’s aggressive behavior, consult the vet or trainer.
  • Do not let your dog see the remote: E-collars are activated with remotes to control the dogs. Since these collars cause irritation and discomfort to the dog’s skin, make sure your dog does not see the remote otherwise, he will feel uncomfortable. An aggressive dog might attack their owners if they see their masters are causing discomfort for them.
  • Train your pooch safely: E-collars train your dog effectively, even in destructive situations. You must ignore your pooch if he is not following your commands but give him treats or rewards if he complies with your orders. Also, patting and treating your dog is one of the best ways to praise him for his good behavior, such as stopping chewing items, barking at people, and other severe habits.

Correcting Uncontrollable Actions

   It depends on the dog’s pace to learn new habits and commands. If your dog is uncontrollable and aggressive, it might take time to train them. You must be kind to your dog while training. It is crucial to use verbal commands while using e-collars. Use your kind wisdom when using e-collar.

   For instance, if your dog has damaging behavior that can hurt him, such as chewing the electronic wires or components that cause death so, make sure to act quickly by using a suitable setting. You can use the three-quick push technique on the e-collar remote in emergencies. That means you can soon catch the attention of your pup.

   It would be best to use the three-quick push technique in deadly situations. Otherwise, you can use it once to the right your dog’s behavior. Do not misuse the shock collar, so your dog stays healthy and happy. Ensure that your dog never sees you activating the remote because this way, your dog will feel fearful, angry, and distrustful.

   Also, it can harm the relationship between you and your dog. So, always behave kind and friendly to your dog while using the e-collar. This way, your dog will trust, love, and will play with you.

Advantages and Disadvantages of E-collar

Advantages and Disadvantages of E-collar

   Here are the advantages and disadvantages of e-collars:


  • E-collar is an efficient and powerful training tool.
  • It offers multiple settings to utilize it.
  • It also keeps your dog secure and safe.
  • E-collar is helpful for aggressive behavior.
  • It is secure for your dog.


  • It might cause anxiety in your dogs.
  • It will cause issues if not used properly.

Checkout Our these Guides:

What are Shock Collars?

What are Shock Collars

   E-collar is a substitute for a shock collar, and the words are comparable. Although there are basic differences, since shock collars were also introduced in 1970, the technology has advanced. These collars were primeval, and some gave the dogs a considerable shock. Still, these collars do not hurt your dog and provoke their sense organs.

Are Shock Collars Cruel for Dogs?

   Shock collars are completely safe for your dog but can cause issues if not used properly. Also, do not overuse shock collars; otherwise, it can lead to anxiety, aggression, and fear in dogs. These collars utilize negative augmentation as a training tool by abolishing lousy behavior. So, many expert trainers disagree with negative augmentation.

Types of Shock Collars

   The three types of shock collars are remote training collars, fence containment collars, and anti-bark collars. These three types of shock collars work similarly but are used for different purposes, such as for the most aggressive behavior of dogs.  

   Fence containment collars will shock the dog if they cross all boundaries of bad behavior and alert your dog with a beeping or chirping sound. Also, anti-bark and remote training collars work simultaneously by conducting shock using a handheld sender.    

Advantages and Disadvantages of Shock Collar

Advantages and Disadvantages of Shock Collar

   Here are the advantages and disadvantages of the shock collar:


  • Shock collars are safe for dogs.
  • These are used for the worst behavior of dogs.
  • It is an effective training collar.
  • It has three different varieties.


  • It functions with negative augmentation.
  • It can harm your pooch if not used right.


Are E-collar and Shock Collar the Same?

   However, these collars are used comparably. Both collars are not similar. A shock collar is a category of e-collar that give a shock to your dog when it is activated.

Do E-collars Hurt Dogs?

   Well, it depends on the dog’s temperament and personality. Some dogs might feel hurt while using e-collars, but some do not mind it at all. Basically, it depends on the owner whether an e-collar is suitable for his dog or not.

Should the Dog Wear an E-collar all Day?

   Dogs mostly wear e-collars for 9 to 10 hours daily without skin issues. But still, it is essential to put off the collar after a few hours to prevent skin problems.

Do Professional Dog Trainers use Shock Collars?

   No, they do not utilize shock collars. Shock collars are supposed to be cruel and are not efficient for training.

Can a Shock Collar Cause Brain Damage?

   Well, many ask this question. Usually, shock collars do not cause any brain damage. But still, they can make existing problems.

Wrapping up

   Almost there is no difference between shock collar and e-collar. Animal activists who do not want to shock their dogs sparked the debate with a linguistic point of view. However, if you correctly use an e-collar or shock collar, your dog will not hurt. Also, always use the lowest shock setting at the beginning of training and slowly increase it if necessary.

   So, it is an excellent way to train your stubborn dogs. I hope this information helps you a lot. If you find this blog helpful, share it. Also, for any questions or suggestions, comment below; I’d respond as soon as possible. Thanks for reading!

Want to Learn More? Checkout Our Product review Articles:

Marian Haaz
Marian is a cat adoption expert. She has rescued and adopted several cats herself and helped find homes for dozens of stray cats and dogs.
Photo of author

Leave a Comment